Madelyn Niemeyer Real Estate Broker

ph: 828.782.3257

Asheville has always felt like home. The culture coupled with the genuine people and draw of the mountains are a driving force for her business.
Read MoreLess

Fun Facts About Me

What was your favorite vacation?

A spontaneous trip to NYC to see the ball drop! Ask me about it!

Childhood nickname?

The Joker, but only because I am always smiling. Why so serious?

Best name for your pet?

Junie, after Junia, historical half-sister to Brutus. We had a mastiff named Brutus.

Most embarrassing hobby?

Karaoke. I'm the person who is no good, but puts on a great show!

Quote that you live by?

The will to win is nothing without the will to prepare.

Most People Wouldn't Think:

I love football and bar food.

My Listings



Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.

Recently Sold

Reviews on Zillow for Madelyn Niemeyer

Rating: 4.833333 / 5
(24 Reviews) 4 Most Recent Shown

Real Estate on Zillow
© Zillow, Inc., Use is subject to Terms of Use

  • *****   Highly likely to recommend
    10/26/2022 - vkstamp2
    This is the second home purchase in which I have worked with Madelyn’s team— from showings to closing. Once again they were on top of each level of the process. She and team members showed several listings to me, responding immediately with showings (usually same day if available). Her team contacted me daily through the buying process and made sure I was keenly aware of the next step. They are courteous, prompt, and professional, making sure the process is expedited, that the buyer is protected, and that all the documents are in order in a timely manner. Her team puts the buyer at ease all the way to closing and even beyond! They suggested contractors to help with remodeling—all were efficient, reasonable and did high quality work. I highly recommend this team for excellence, confidence, ease of communication, and QUALITY.
  • *****   Highly likely to recommend
    04/24/2021 - ballen1684
    Madelyn has been our agent for many years now. She has always done an amazing job for us and found us exactly what we need. She has also helped us sell some homes as well as buy and delivers every time.
  • *   Will never recommend
    07/19/2021 - eveshollow
    Unfortunately Madelyn was more talk than action. I was trying to purchase a home remotely from the other side of the country and Madelyn sounded perfect because she claims to specialize in relocation clients. I came across my dream home and in my price range , with room to negotiate higher. I gave her the address to schedule a viewing within an hour of the house coming up for sale. She then proceeded to say she will get a viewing scheduled. Then she ghosted me ... never heard from her again. The house sold within a day or two and I lost my dream home. I never even got the opportunity to compete with the other buyers. I am proud to say I am a home owner now , thanks to another agent and NOT because of Madelyn.
  • *****   Highly likely to recommend
    09/19/2022 - luckeyrob
    She has been great! We purchased three properties and two vacant lots and we had lots of help and support from Madelyn and Andrew. We would definitely recommend her.
  • *****   Highly likely to recommend
    01/05/2019 - david handy1
    Madelyn Niemeyer worked hard to find us a great home for our family. I was in Asheville and my husband was in Fargo and we have a pack of dogs. We set a challenge and she was up for the challenge. Madelyn and her husband negotiated well for us so we could get a great deal. I would highly recommend the Niemeyers !
  • *****   Highly likely to recommend
    09/07/2018 - raaemt724
    Extremely talented, extremely professional. Madelyn has a phenomenal knowledge of the market. She is also 100% responsive, we NEVER had any problem contacting her. She and Andrew were a joy to work with, they made the entire experience (from searching for a house to closing) as easy as it could be. Strongest recommendation possible!Hank & Pat Amann
  • *****   Highly likely to recommend
    08/08/2019 - vicki5438
    Moving cross-country was challenging. Downsizing was challenging. Finding and trusting the right people to help you successfully accomplish an out-of-state transition seemed impossible. And then we met Maddie and Andrew Niemeyer of Nest Realty. Madelyn and Andrew are articulate, intelligent, compassionate, and have more integrity than anyone in sales that we have ever encountered. Allow me to site some examples:1.) We were retiring, but not with a specific timeline. We were trying to sell our business and home 1,000 miles from where we were hoping to live in Western NC, and had no idea how long that would take, or truthfully what the proceeds would be. Madelyn and Andrew treated our situation as if it didn't matter to them at all if it took 3 months for us to be able to buy a house, or 3 years. (And not because we were "big" buyers. The home we would ultimately buy cost less than 350K.) We shopped for homes with them in August 2018, then 6 months later, and yet another time 3 months after that before we made the purchase.2.) When buying in WNC, your won't be short on options for realtors. But beware, and check reviews and referrals!! Madelyn and Andrew are not phased by the sometimes remote areas of WNC, and their knowledge of the area paid off for us. They knew the ins-and-outs of every town/neighborhood where we were looking, and when they weren't sure, they knew people who could answer our questions (which were many!) and they got me answers.3.) My calls to Andrew and Madelyn were more than a few. I tried so hard to not bombard them with constant calls (and results of Zillow findings!) but they never seemed to be bothered, and they ALWAYS responded. After several days of house hunting (the 3rd time!) I had given up on one particular house because it seemed too far away. The next day, Andrew told me we were gonna go there; that we didn't want to miss out on what might be right for us. And guess what? It was the right house for us. Without him taking the lead and convincing me we needed to make the extra effort, I would have never seen this fabulous house that we now call home. 4.) I will forever be grateful for the integrity of Andrew when he sat me down and specifically asked me the "hard" questions about the area we chose. (Somewhat remote by some people's standards.) He gently reminded me of the road hazards in bad weather. He talked to me about the need to be prepared for winter by researching generators and even cars! (Yes, we bought the car he told us to buy!) He even made sure I knew that the nearest grocery store was 20+ minutes away! I knew then that these two really CARE about their clients. They are not concerned with how fast they can get their 3% and move on to the next client. 5.) We had a few hiccups in the contract/closing process. Madelyn can crack a whip. She didn't back down, and she had our best intentions every single time. At the end of the day, THEY got it done, and we are in a home that we couldn't possibly love more. And we owe it all to Andrew and Madelyn. Just meet this beautiful kind husband/wife team. You will not find another couple of realtors in WNC who can get the job done so efficiently. And when it's all over, and the contracts are signed, you will want to be friends forever. That just doesn't happen in this business very often.
  • *****   Highly likely to recommend
    07/28/2021 - zuser20150328204122938
    We are so happy to be working with Madelyn Niemeyer and her team once again. She is available and happy to help whenever we have a question about any property. We are looking in the area for the perfect home and her knowledge of what is out there is astounding. Love her teams “get it done attitude. We highly recommend reaching out to the Niemeyer’s at Nest!
  • *****   Highly likely to recommend
    09/17/2018 - ruthrigby2
    My real estate search began with a slight interest in Maggie Valley as a vacation home location. From Trulia click, Maddy and Andrew contacted me. Not knowing very much about the area, I was given links to get me started. There was no sales pressure. All my questions about the area were answered, so I committed to a couple days search with Maddy. We saw several homes that matched my criteria. Unexpectedly, and with Maddy's guidance, I shifted to a more upscale version of mountain home than originally planned. This completely aligned with my goal. The contract process was professional and timely each step of the way. Maddy's contacts and professional connections gave me expert service thru the inspection, insurance, and attorney processes. I feel as if my interests were primary, and our good relationship will be in place for a long time.
  • *****   Highly likely to recommend
    02/19/2019 - erather002
    Madelyn is the real deal as a realtor and a person. She was our buyer’s agent and she was open and transparent with us. She was laid back and didn’t shove a buyer’s contract at us to sign. She worked more on a trust/faith relationship with us and didn’t want us to feel obligated to stay with her. She is extremely knowledgeable and knows her stuff! She’s not afraid to get dirty either; she has no problem going under crawl spaces to check things out thoroughly! She’s awesome and would highly recommend her! We’ve worked with a lot of real estate agents and Madelyn is hands down the best we’ve ever had the pleasure of knowing and working with.

Join our Newsletter

×